On the first day of deliberations, the jury in the Adam Fravel murder trial did not come to a verdict. 

Attorneys presented their closing arguments Wednesday in the trial of Adam Fravel, who is accused of murdering Madeline Kingsbury, his former partner and the mother of his children. The case is now in the hands of the jury.

Deliberating for around seven hours, they ended the night at 9:30 p.m., which was the time set by the judge in the case. With two hours left in the night, the jury did have a few questions for the judge, including asking for clarification surrounding premeditation and if Fravel could be found guilty on all charges, which he could. 

The jury is sequestered, meaning they are staying at a hotel with no access to media and can not communicate with anyone. They’ll pick up deliberations at 8 a.m. on Thursday. 

Fravel is charged with first- and second-degree murder in Kingsbury’s death last year. He faces a life sentence if convicted on the more serious charge.

As previously reported, Kingsbury first disappeared from her home on March 31, 2023. A large-scale search effort soon ramped up in southeastern Minnesota, and Kingsbury’s body was found taped up in a bedsheet off of a country road in Fillmore County in June 2023.

Prosecutors built a case painting Fravel as an abusive partner who had remarked about Kingsbury ending up like Gabby Petito, a social media influencer who was strangled to death by her boyfriend.

During their closing arguments Wednesday, the prosecution said Fravel had the motive, the opportunity and the means to kill Kingsbury.

Prosecuting attorney Phillip Prokopowicz highlighted the couple’s breakup and Kingsbury’s decision to start dating an old friend. He said Fravel was “emotionally and financially dependent” on Kingsbury, was jealous of her new relationship and “would never allow another man to raise his children.”

The defense, meanwhile, worked to downplay allegations of abuse and cast doubt on the investigation into Kingsbury’s death and the search for her remains.

On Wednesday, Fravel’s attorneys argued law enforcement had “tunnel vision” targeting Fravel during the case, and “when the facts didn’t fit their case, it was thrown out, not investigated.”

Defense attorney Zachary Bauer refuted the prosecution’s narrative that Fravel and Kingsbury had broken up and even asserted that the two were discussing having more kids together and getting married.

Closing arguments wrapped up around 1:30 p.m. Jurors received their instructions and have been given until 9:30 to deliberate. Since no verdict was reached, they will pick up again on Thursday.

Winona County District Judge Nancy Buytendorp agreed to move the trial to Blue Earth County due to the extensive pretrial publicity in the Winona area. Even with the move, jury selection took a week and a half before both sides found 12 jurors and five alternates. Both sides gave their opening statements on Oct. 17.

According to sister station KAAL, prosecutors brought 68 witnesses to the stand over the course of two weeks, including Kingsbury’s parents, law enforcement investigators and forensic scientists.

Fravel’s defense team called on five witnesses, including two law enforcement officers, Fravel’s brother, and neighbors of the couple’s home in Winona and Fravel’s parents in Mabel. Fravel did not testify in his own defense.

The defense rested its case on Friday, and the court took a two-day recess to start this week to accommodate Election Day voting.