Ramsey County Attorney’s Office announces intent to retry man charged in St. Paul shooting

Monday, the Ramsey County Attorney’s Office announced its intent to retry a man charged in connection to a May 2020 shooting in St. Paul.

Anthony James Trifiletti was charged with one count of second-degree murder in the fatal shooting of Douglas Lewis.

Last week, a mistrial was declared in Trifiletti’s case after a jury could not reach a verdict.

According to a criminal complaint, St. Paul police were called on the night of May 1, 2020, on the report of a shooting on the 1300 block of Burns Avenue.

A Ramsey County case is declared a mistrial, what that means going forward

When police arrived, they found Lewis, who had suffered multiple gunshot wounds. Lewis was later pronounced dead at an area hospital.

According to the complaint, officers found Trifiletti near the scene, and he told officers he had a handgun in the glove box.

The complaint states Trifiletti told police his GPS instructed him to exit onto Burns Avenue from Highway 61, and when he turned right the right rear corner of his vehicle was bumped from behind.

He told police he pulled to the side of the road and Lewis began to yell at him. Fearing Lewis might have a weapon, Trifiletti told police he told his friends in another truck to leave. Lewis then got out of his car and Trifiletti shot him several times. The complaint states officers found four 9mm shell casings on the ground in the area.

A witness told police Trifiletti and Lewis were at least 10 feet from each other at the time of the shooting and she didn’t see anything in Lewis’s hands. After the shooting, the witness help render aid to Lewis, the complaint states.

Trifiletti later told police a Ford hit his vehicle from behind, and they pulled to the side of the road. He said he talked to Lewis and asked for his insurance information but Lewis yelled that he wanted Trifiletti’s information.

After asking again for Lewis’s insurance information, Trifiletti said Lewis yelled something about a gang that Trifiletti didn’t understand. Trifiletti then said he walked back to his truck and grabbed his 9mm handgun to put in his waistband holster. Lewis then started to pull away in his vehicle and Trifiletti did, too, but said he unintentionally followed Lewis.

According to the complaint, Trifiletti said Lewis then stopped his vehicle, got out and put his hand under his shirt. That’s when Trifiletti said he fired his gun three or four times at Lewis because he was afraid he was going to die. Trifiletti then left the scene, called his father and told him what happened. He said his father told him to go back to the scene, so he did.

Trifiletti also told police he didn’t think just driving away was an option because he though Lewis would shoot at him.