Safety Engineer: EPA Should Be Required to Conduct Annual Inspections of Oil Refineries

September 27, 2018 07:07 PM

A safety engineer in St. Paul says a 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS investigation has put a spotlight on oil refineries that store a toxic chemical and the federal agency tasked with regulating them.

David Sullivan-Nightengale, who has spent the past 18 years inspecting safety equipment in industrial plants for private companies, says the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) should be reviewing safety plans every year at refineries that use large amounts of hydrogen fluoride.


Hydrogen fluoride is a highly toxic chemical used to improve the quality of gasoline.

“An annual inspection of the safety systems should be required,” Sullivan-Nightengale said.

Yet, a 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS investigation found the EPA had never inspected the Husky Energy refinery in Superior, Wisconsin, prior to an explosion last April.

RELATED: Superior Refinery that Stored Toxic Chemical was Never Inspected by EPA Prior to Explosion

On Thursday, Rep. Rick Nolan (D-Minn.), who represents a district near that refinery, called those findings “extremely troubling.”

The town of Superior was forced to evacuate after the explosion because city leaders feared hydrogen fluoride could leak if a storage tank ruptured.

A spokesperson for Husky Energy says its safety plans had adequately prepared the surrounding community.

Sullivan-Nightengale said annual inspections are necessary because the chemical is so corrosive.

“I've seen what happens when hydrogen fluoride is stored too long in a spot,” he said. “It will eat through stainless steel over time.”

RELATED: Superior Refinery Explosion Occurred during Crude Oil Heating, Extraction Process

The chemical is also stored at the Andeavor refinery in St. Paul Park – in the Twin Cities metro.

A spokesperson for Andeavor said its emergency plans “comply with all regulatory requirements” and are reviewed and approved by the EPA.

However, a 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS found the EPA has not inspected that refinery since June 2007.

RELATED: Report: Worn Valve Caused Explosion at Superior Refinery

A spokesperson for the EPA said the agency "assumes a company, a well-run company, has taken proper safety procedures," and does not have enough inspectors to conduct regular reviews of safety plans.

“You would not have proper oversight with those gaps…absolutely not,” Sullivan-Nightengale said.


Joe Augustine

Copyright 2018 - KSTP-TV, LLC A Hubbard Broadcasting Company


Milaca schools working on snowmobile solution

Proposed gas tax increase 'unlikely' to pass, according to KSTP analyst

KSTP Sports 2019 Girls State Hockey Tourney Central

Heavy snow to fall overnight, throughout the day Wednesday

Authorities in Cloquet seek missing 20-year-old