ACLU Sues Faribault over Rental Housing Ordinance Claiming it's Discriminatory

June 13, 2018 07:14 PM

The American Civil Liberties Union is suing the City of Faribault over what it calls an unconstitutional rental housing ordinance that discriminates against people of color.

The organization filed the lawsuit Wednesday morning in federal court.


RELATED: ACLU: Child Porn Charges Against Rice County Teen Dropped

The suit alleges that the city’s rental licensing ordinance was enacted with the intent to push minority families out of downtown Faribault.

Under the ordinance, landlords are required to evict tenants if police are called to a property as few as three times and identify a “disorderly conduct” violation.

The ordinance also requires landlords to do background checks on all tenants before they hand over the keys.

RELATED: ACLU Minnesota Criticizes Changes to Minneapolis Police Body Camera Policy

“I just think it's unfair,” said Thelma Jones who rented a home in Faribault for her family of five until last year when the city forced the landlord to evict them.

“I don’t have a criminal background. My daughter doesn’t have a criminal background," Jones said. "It’s not fair."

In this case, since police paid multiple visits for what the ACLU described as petty issues, such as noise complaints, the family racked up disorderly conduct violations.

RELATED: ACLU Sues Over Plans for Citizenship Question on 2020 Census

The city ordinance says three strikes, and you’re out.

“If the police have certified that a qualifying offense has occurred on the property – that's enough. It doesn’t have to lead to an arrest much less a conviction,” said Teresa Nelson, ACLU attorney.

Nelson calls the ordinance unconstitutional and one of the worst in the country.

RELATED: ACLU: Amazon Shouldn't Sell Face-Recognition Tech to Police

It’s why the organization is suing the city over policies it feels discriminates against the city’s growing minority population.

“The guidance from HUD is just that. The people of color are more likely to have a criminal conviction and so having housing policies that deny housing for someone with a criminal conviction is racial discrimination,” Nelson said.

Faribault city attorneys see it differently.

In a four-page letter sent to the ACLU earlier this week, the city called the claims “unsubstantiated” and stated it will “not pursue a repeal of the ordinance” as requested by the organization.

Robert Alsop, City Attorney, writes that the ordinance “was adopted as a legitimate police power of the city” to regulate housing standards.

He adds that nowhere does it say landlords cannot rent to people with a record.

The letter also states that the ACLU failed to provide any evidence in the suit that shows minority families are disproportionately impacted by the city’s ordinance.

Meanwhile, the ACLU says it looks forward to responding in court where “we believe our claims will prevail.”


Ryan Raiche

Copyright 2018 - KSTP-TV, LLC A Hubbard Broadcasting Company


Brooklyn Park boy finds needle in toy from Elk River Walmart

St. Paul police investigating homicide in Payne-Phalen neighborhood, suspect at large

Ilhan Omar: Go to Israel, see 'cruel reality of the occupation'

Moorhead police ask for public's help locating missing 14-year-old

Planned Parenthood leaves federal family planning program