Planned Parenthood to resume offering abortions next week in Wisconsin, citing court ruling
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Planned Parenthood announced Thursday that it will resume offering abortions in Wisconsin next week after a judge ruled that an 1849 law that seemingly banned the procedure actually didn’t apply to abortions.
The resumption of abortions Monday at clinics in Milwaukee and Madison comes as the lawsuit challenging the state law continues in county court. It is expected to eventually reach the Wisconsin Supreme Court, which flipped to liberal control on Aug. 1.
Abortion clinics across the state stopped offering abortions following the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling overturning Roe v. Wade in June 2022. Until then, Wisconsin’s decades-old statutes — interpreted to outlaw abortion in all cases except to save a mother’s life — were effectively nullified by the 1973 Roe ruling providing a right to abortion nationwide.
“PPWI needed to do that to protect providers from the possibility of being charged,” said Tanya Atkinson, president of Planned Parenthood of Wisconsin, said Thursday.
Democratic Attorney General Josh Kaul filed a lawsuit in Dane County days after Roe v. Wade was overturned, seeking to repeal the ban.
Kaul argues that the ban is too old to enforce and that a 1985 law that permits abortions before a fetus can survive outside the womb supersedes the ban. Three doctors later joined the lawsuit as plaintiffs, saying they fear being prosecuted for performing abortions.
Dane County Circuit Judge Diane Schlipper ruled in July that Wisconsin’s 173-year-old abortion ban outlaws killing fetuses but doesn’t apply to consensual medical abortions. Her ruling, a victory for those fighting the ban, said that the legal language in the 1849 law doesn’t use the term “abortion” so it only prohibits attacking a woman in an attempt to kill her unborn child.
“With the recent confirmation from the Court that there is not an enforceable abortion ban in Wisconsin, our staff can now provide the full scope of sexual and reproductive health care to anyone in Wisconsin who needs it, no matter what,” said Atkinson.
According to a PPWI spokesperson, patients will be able to obtain an abortion up to 20 weeks from the last day of the menstrual period. The patient is required to have an in-person appointment with a physician and go over the state’s mandatory informed consent form. A 24-hour wait period follows. Patients seeking medication abortion are required to see the same physician in person for both the consenting appointment and the appointment where medication is received.
Planned Parenthood of Wisconsin plans to expand access to appointments to return to pre-Dobbs levels in the coming weeks.
Laura Hermer, a Mitchell Hamline School of Law professor, explained Judge Schlipper’s decision was limited to a motion to dismiss.
“All it does is say the case can continue,” she said. “It doesn’t set any precedent.”
A final judgement in the case is still ahead and then there may be appeals.
“Given this announcement from Planned Parenthood, it suggests to me that they’re feeling pretty bullish about how this case is going to come out — not just at the district court but if it is appealed at the appellate level as well,” said Hermer.
Planned Parenthood clinics in Illinois, where abortion has remained widely available, have seen a seven-fold increase of patients from neighboring Wisconsin since the U.S. Supreme Court’s June 2022 abortion ruling, according to Planned Parenthood of Illinois.
“More access to care benefits everyone,” said PPIL president and CEO Jennifer Welch in a press release Thursday.
Currently, abortion is banned throughout pregnancy — with limited exceptions — in 14 states. Bans are being enforced in two more when cardiac activity can be detected, generally around six weeks into pregnancy and often before women know they’re pregnant. Judges have put enforcement of restrictions on hold in at least four additional states.
A divided federal government has ensured that there won’t be a nationwide ban or legalization immediately, and most states with liberal governments have taken steps to try to protect abortion access.
Most of Wisconsin’s closest neighboring states — Minnesota, Illinois and Michigan — have maintained that abortion is generally legal up to at least 24 weeks of pregnancy. Indiana’s near-total ban on abortion took effect in August. In Iowa, abortion remains legal up to 20 weeks of pregnancy as a court challenge continues against the state’s new measure banning most abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy.
Democrats in Wisconsin, including Gov. Tony Evers, used abortion access as a central focus of their reelection victories in 2022. State Supreme Court Justice Janet Protasiewicz, whose win in April gave liberals the majority for the first time in 15 years, ran as a supporter of abortion rights.
Evers hailed Planned Parenthood’s decision to resume abortions.
“This is critically important news for Wisconsin women and patients across our state who, for a year now, have been unable to access the healthcare they need when and where they need it,” he said in a statement.
Abortions were available at three Planned Parenthood clinics in Wisconsin prior to the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe. A spokesperson said staffing levels allow for two clinics to do so now but the organization hopes to return to its former availability.
Julaine Appling, president of the anti-abortion group Wisconsin Family Action, called the move “audacious” and said the state ban remains in effect.
“No court has ruled that it is not enforceable,” Appling said. “It is still illegal in most instances for anyone to do an abortion in Wisconsin. So what the governor and Planned Parenthood are doing is promoting an illegal activity. Unfortunately, this illegal activity is life-taking because it’s the intentional killing of an unborn child.”
Alison Dreith, director of strategic partnerships for the Midwest Access Coalition, said the organization assisted 134 people from Wisconsin last year and 81 so far this year who needed assistance accessing abortions away from their home state — trailing only Indiana among upper Midwest states.
“I’m elated for what this is going to mean for people living in Wisconsin and for the abortion safety net as a whole,” Dreith said.
Wisconsin Democratic Senate Minority Leader Melissa Agard echoed comments of other Democrats who praised the decision, but said “we have an awful lot of work to do here in Wisconsin to ensure that a woman’s right to choose is protected and codified in perpetuity.”
Kaul wrote in a statement:
“Fundamental reproductive health-care decisions should be made by women, but for over a year, the freedom of Wisconsin has been impaired due to the lack of clarity about state law regarding abortion. My administration has consistently take the position that, notwithstanding the Supreme Court’s decision to overrule Roe v. Wade, the 1849 law cannot be enforced in cases involving consensual abortions, and a circuit court judge, in a decision on a motion to dismiss, concluded that the 1849 law applies to feticide, not consensual abortion. Litigation remains ongoing, and we will continue to fight for a final judgement that conclusively resolves this issue.”
Associated Press writers Harm Venhuizen, Sara Burnett, Geoff Mulvihill, Claire Savage and Kathleen Foody contributed to this report.
Copyright 2023 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.